Welcome To Website IAS

Hot news
Achievement

Independence Award

- First Rank - Second Rank - Third Rank

Labour Award

- First Rank - Second Rank -Third Rank

National Award

 - Study on food stuff for animal(2005)

 - Study on rice breeding for export and domestic consumption(2005)

VIFOTEC Award

- Hybrid Maize by Single Cross V2002 (2003)

- Tomato Grafting to Manage Ralstonia Disease(2005)

- Cassava variety KM140(2010)

Centres
Website links
Vietnamese calendar
Library
Visitors summary
 Curently online :  5
 Total visitors :  7484383

Climate change and agricultural suicides in India
Thursday, 2018/01/11 | 07:36:08

Kamal Kumar Murari, T. Jayaraman, and Madhura Swaminathan

PNAS January 9, 2017

Carleton (1) claims that “temperature during India’s main agricultural growing season has a strong positive effect on annual suicide rates.” Using state-scale panel data for 1967–2013, the author suggests that an increase in 1 °C temperature in a single day can cause 70 suicides. The evidence, she argues, is consistent with “an agriculture channel in which heat damages crops,” resulting in economic hardship and suicide.

 

There are flaws in the data and assumptions used by Carleton (1).

 

The data on deaths from suicide are from the National Crime Records Bureau. The problem of underreporting in data from police records is recognized, though not that the degree of underreporting may vary across states and time. There are serious concerns about the consistency of data before 1995 (2). Carelton (1) has used state-level suicide data, that is, data for urban and rural areas combined of a state. Can one relate the rate of urban suicides to climatic factors?

 

The second dependent variable is crop yield measured in value terms (rupees per hectare per year at fixed 1960–1965 prices) for an index of major crops (rice, wheat, sugar, sorghum, millet, and maize). Cotton, a major crop in the regions with concentrations of farmer suicides, is excluded.

 

The two main independent variables are cumulative rainfall and temperature. For temperature, the variable, daily degree days, is defined as the difference between actual and threshold temperature. Notwithstanding sensitivity analysis, the assumption of a temperature threshold of 20 °C is inappropriate. Every crop has a specific temperature threshold, ranging from 33 °C to 38 °C, above which a negative impact on yields is possible (3). Indeed, temperatures in the range of 20 °C to 29 °C are viewed as favorable for crop growth (4, 5).

 

The assumption of growing (June to September) and nongrowing seasons (rest of the year) is incorrect. India has two major growing seasons, the monsoon and the winter season. Research indicates that crop yields are most sensitive to temperature variations in the latter (6). Not separating the winter crop season from the other months of the year is an error.

 

The author finds a strong positive coefficient when aggregate state-level deaths from suicide are regressed on degree days in the growing season. The quality of data on suicides is in doubt, and the definitions of temperature threshold and growing season are incorrect. The author refers to robustness checks but retains the erroneous assumptions. Without further study, it is not clear how we interpret the observed coefficient.

 

Results on the negative effect of temperature on crop yields are not tenable. Of the six crops pooled, rice is mainly a monsoon crop, wheat is a winter crop, and sugarcane is a 12- to 18-mo crop. How can the July–September temperature explain changes in the combined yields of these crops? The author ignores the literature on crop-specific effects of temperature on yield (3, 5).

 

The data and their interpretation do not support claims of a temperature-related agricultural explanation for farmer suicides, an outcome of multiple factors.

 

See: http://www.pnas.org/content/115/2/E115.full

Back      Print      View: 362

[ Other News ]___________________________________________________
  • Beyond genes: Protein atlas scores nitrogen fixing duet
  • 2016 Borlaug CAST Communication Award Goes to Dr. Kevin Folta
  • FAO and NEPAD team up to boost rural youth employment in Benin, Cameroon, Malawi and Niger
  • Timely seed distributions in Ethiopia boost crop yields, strengthen communities’ resilience
  • Parliaments must work together in the final stretch against hunger
  • Empowering women farmers in the polder communities of Bangladesh
  • Depression: let’s talk
  • As APEC Concludes, CIP’s Food Security and Climate Smart Agriculture on Full Display
  • CIAT directly engages with the European Cocoa Industry
  • Breeding tool plays a key role in program planning
  • FAO: Transform Agriculture to Address Global Challenges
  • Uganda Holds Banana Research Training for African Scientists and Biotechnology Regulators
  • US Congress Ratifies Historic Global Food Security Treaty
  • Fruit Fly`s Genetic Code Revealed
  • Seminar at EU Parliament Tackles GM Crops Concerns
  • JICA and IRRI ignites a “seed revolution” for African and Asian farmers
  • OsABCG26 Vital in Anther Cuticle and Pollen Exine Formation in Rice
  • Akira Tanaka, IRRI’s first physiologist, passes away
  • WHO calls for immediate safe evacuation of the sick and wounded from conflict areas
  • Farmer Field School in Tonga continues to break new ground in the Pacific for training young farmers

 

Designed & Powered by WEBSO CO.,LTD